A book is a book, part 2
A book is a book, part 2
My generation often grumbles about “social media” on the internet. But I confess that my surrender to Facebook has bestowed unexpected delights.
I taught and coached at Oxbow High School for 16 years. That’s a lot of kids under the bridge. In the past, I would occasionally run into former students, and it was a pleasure to hear how their lives have evolved.
Facebook, however, transformed that trickle into a stream of reconnections with nearly 200 “kids” who used to sit in my classroom or wield fencing foils under my command. Beyond brief encounters, I now see pictures of their homes, hobbies and children.
Best of all, we exchange ideas, life philosophies, and political rantings. The meaty stuff not usually on the table in chance encounters.
So last week, when Bunker Hill Publishing posted my column “A Book is a Book” on their website, I asked my Facebook friends to read it and weigh in with their preferences: books, eBooks, or both.
Their responses were so eloquent and interesting, I quickly shot off messages asking permission to quote them.
Dan Gilson, who now lives in Alaska, likes his eReader “because it takes up the space of about one book yet can contain the wisdom and entertainment of thousands of books.” He was one of several respondents to mention this valuable characteristic.
But, Dan notes, his eReader is “missing something.”
“I call it the ‘romantic notion of a book,’” he writes.
“When I have a book in my hands, I can flip back and forth between pages, write in the margin, place a bookmark in ‘my spot.’ I can stick pieces of paper containing notes between the pages. I can dog ear pages. I can place the open pages on my chest when I fall asleep.”
“When I pick up an old book,” Dan continued, “I can wonder whose hands have held it, whose eyes have scanned its pages.”
Keith Stockwell finds that when reading on computers, “I seldom want to read more than a page or two at a time. Something in the nature of it just urges me to flit betwixt that page and some random website, then email, and so forth, like a sparrow by the McDonald’s dumpster.”
While he admits that eReaders are nicer, “Books, real dead-tree editions, will always hold a special place. There is something different and warm and calm about them. There is nothing to break (except the spine, I suppose), nothing to fail or have a bad switch or return for warranty, no issues with some formats not being supported.”
“It is a book,” Keith concludes, “a thing that simply works.”
While Dan and Keith accept both, Tina Gilson differs emphatically.
“REAL books only for me,” she writes. “I will never read a book off an electronic device. I love books, I love bookstores. An eReader will never replace the real deal!”
This is one of those times when word count limitations here bedevil me. There are so many wonderful reflections on books from my former students…
Stay tuned for more next week.
(by permission Journal Opinion)

















